Engineered for optimum squidginess. Filled with both choc-chips that melt when warmed, fresh raspberry jelly and a tonne of peanut butter... there's not much this pie has left behind.
This cake can be reserved for collection from all stores apart from Surry Hills and The Star – for collection from these stores, you can visit us in store. We have a limited number of cakes available in every store each day. You can drop in and purchase a cake (subject to stock) anytime we’re open or call ahead to make sure we have the one you want. If you’re planning for an event, we recommend you call ahead or buy online as we can’t guarantee the one you want will be there! Give us a call. We’re really nice…
Online cake orders require a 2-day turnaround.
If you don’t have 2 days, visit any store and buy from the selection they have available, or give them a call 24 hours before to reserve one. If it’s for a special occasion, we highly recommend ordering ahead.
Our recommended safe travel time for cakes is 30 mins from store to freezer. If it’s a hot day, use your noggin… and make the trip snappy! If you want to extend your travel time, bring a cooler bag or esky.
To enhance the flavours and assist in cutting, the cake should be removed from the freezer and placed in the fridge 20 mins before serving. Always use a hot, sharp knife and ensure you wipe off any excess water to prevent depositing ice crystals on the cake.
We also sell candles which you can order online or pick up in store. All stores offer HAPPY BIRTHDAY plaques. Orders made in advance for collection from Rosebery or Fitzroy also have the option to add a name to the plaque.
*If you're running late for your pick up in stores, no need to let us know... we'll hold onto it until you make it in.
The PBJ has been engineered for optimum squidginess. Filled with both choc-chips that melt when warmed, fresh raspberry jelly and a tonne of peanut butter... there's not much this pie has left behind. We recommend serving with a big scoop of vanilla gelato and if you're game, add a glug of our new toppings.
HOW TO GET A PBJ PIE IN SYD, QLD, CANBERRA
HOW TO GET A PBJ PIE IF YOU'RE IN MELB
*Allergens: nuts, dairy, egg, gluten
Once your pie's at home, bung in the oven for 20, watch it bubble and dig into a melted, peanut buttery centre. Top with your favourite scoops, toppings (if you dare) and voila!
AS STOCK ARE LIMITED, PLEASE KEEP AN EYE ON OUR INSTA - WE'LL POST WHEN EACH STORE SELLS OUT!
PBJ Cookie Pie on it's own - $20
PBJ Cookie Pie + 500ml tub - $28 (would be $34.80, save $6.80)
PBJ Cookie Pie + 1ltr tub - $36 (would be $44.80, save $8.80)
PBJ Cookie Pie + 1.5ltr - $39 (would be $49, save $10.00)
Refrigerate until ready to bake. Serves 2-6
1. Pre-heat oven to 170C / 340F
2. Bake for 20 mins (it's ready when it's cooked through)
3. Remove from oven and serve with your choice of Messina gelato
If you've got enough willpower to save this more than 3 days, please freeze.
*Allergens: nuts, dairy, egg & gluten
Refunds on Pre-Ordered Products
If you need to cancel your order, you can do so by notifying us 2 days before your pick up date. To cancel, please email email@example.com with your order number.
If you already have the Messina app, you don't have to do anything. We'll email your points a few days after purchasing the PBJ Cookie Pie.
Don't have our app? Need a bit of convincing? Every time you make a purchase in store with our mobile app or buy select products through our website, you'll receive 10 Messina App points per dollar you spend. You're the boss of your points. They add up to free gelato and other cool things which you can redeem as and when you please. Download the Messina app before 9am Monday 13th July to claim your Cookie Pie points.